Abstract
We review critical issues that must be considered when selectingindicator species for a monitoring program that aims to maintainor restore ecological integrity. First, we examine the pros andcons of different management approaches on which a conservationprogram can be based and conclude that ecosystem management ismost appropriate. We then identify potential indicators ofecological integrity at various levels of the ecosystem, with aparticular emphasis on the species level. We conclude that,although the use of indicator species remains contentious, it canbe useful if (1) many species representing various taxa and lifehistories are included in the monitoring program, (2) theirselection is primarily based on a sound quantitative databasefrom the focal region, and (3) caution is applied wheninterpreting their population trends to distinguish actualsignals from variations that may be unrelated to thedeterioration of ecological integrity. Finally, we present anddiscuss different methods that have been used to select indicatorspecies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams, M. J.: 1999, 'Correlated factors in amphibian declines: exotic species and habitat change in western Washington', J. Wild. Manag. 63, 1162–1171.
Beintema, A. J.: 1983, 'Meadow birds as indicators', Environ. Monit. Assess. 3, 391–398.
Block, W. M., Brennan, L. A. and Gutiérrez, R. J.: 1987, 'Evaluation of guild-indicator species for use in resource management', Env. Manage. 11, 265–269.
Bost, C. and Mayo, Y.: 1993, 'Seabirds as bioindicators of changing marine ecosystems: new perspectives', Acta Oecol. 14, 463–470.
Bradford, D. F., Franson, S. E., Neale, A. C., Heggem, D. T., Miller, G. R. and Canterbury, G. E.: 1998, 'Bird species assemblages as indicators of biological integrity in Great Basin rangeland', Environ. Monit. Assess. 49, 1–22.
Brooks, R. P., O'Connell, T. J., Wardrop, D. H. and Jackson, L. E.: 1998, 'Towards a regional index of biological integrity: the example of forested riparian ecosystems', Environ. Monit. Assess. 51, 131–143.
Brunner, R. D. and Clark, T. W.: 1997, 'A practice-based approach to ecosystem management', Conserv. Biol. 11, 48–58.
Buzas, M. A.: 1972, 'Patterns of species diversity and their explanation', Taxon 21, 275–286.
Cairns, J. Jr. and Van der Shalie, W. H.: 1980, Biological monitoring: Part I-early warning systems', Water Res. 14, 1179–1190.
Calow, P.: 1992, 'Can ecosystems be healthy? Critical consideration of concepts', J. Aq. Ecosyst. Health 1, 1–5.
Canterbury, G. E., Martin, T. E., Petit, D. R., Petit, L. J. and Bradford, D. F.: 2000, 'Bird communities and habitat as ecological indicators of forest condition in regional monitoring', Conserv. Biol. 14, 544–558.
Christensen, N. L., Bartuska, A. M., Brown, J. H., Carpenter, S., D'Antonio, C., Francis, R., Franklin, J. F., MacMahon, J. A., Noss, R. F., Parsons, D. J., Peterson, C. H., Turner, M. G. and Woodmansee, R. G.: 1996, 'The report of the Ecological Society of America committee on the scientific basis for ecosystem management' Ecol. Appl. 6, 665–691.
Crome, F. H.: 1985, 'Problems of Wildlife Management in Relation to Forestry Practices in the Southern Hemisphere', in: J. Kikkawa, (ed.), Wildlife Management in the Forests and the Forestry-controlled Lands in the Tropics and the Southern Hemisphere. Proceedings of the IUFRO workshop, July 1984, p. 15–21
Daily, G. C., Ehrlich, P. R. and Haddad, N. M.: 1993, 'Double keystone bird in a keystone species complex', Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 90, 592–594.
Davis, G. E.: 1989, 'Design of a long-term ecological monitoring program for Channel Islands National Park, California', Nat. Areas J. 9, 80–89.
de Boer, T. A.: 1983, 'Vegetation as an indicator of environmental changes' Environ. Monit. Assess. 3, 375–380.
di Castri, F., Vernhes, J. R. and Younés, T.: 1992, 'Inventoring and monitoring biodiversity: a proposal for an international network' Biol. Internat. 27, 1–27.
Dufrêne, M. and Legendre, P.: 1997, 'Species assemblages and indicator species: the need for a flexible asymmetrical approach', Ecol. Monogr. 67, 345–366.
Fisher, R. N. and Shaffer, H. B.: 1996, 'The decline of amphibians in California's Great Central Valley', Conserv. Biol. 10, 1387–1397.
Franklin, J. F.: 1993, 'Preserving biodiversity: species, ecosystems, or landscapes?', Ecol. Appl. 3, 202–205.
Gause, G. F.: 1934, The Struggle for Existence. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore (Maryland).
Gibbs, J. P., Snell, H. L. and Gaston, C. E.: 1999, 'Effective monitoring for adaptive wildlife management: lessons from the Galàpagos islands', J. Wildl. Manage. 63, 1055–1065.
Griffith, J. A.: 1997, 'Connecting ecological monitoring and ecological indicators: a review of the literature', J. Env. Systems 26, 325–363.
Grumbine, R. E.: 1994, 'What is ecosystem management?' Conserv. Biol. 8, 27–38.
Hall, H. M. and Grinnell, J.: 1919, 'Life-zone indicators in California', Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci. 9, 37–67.
Hanley, T. A.: 1993, 'Balancing economic development, biological conservation, and human culture: the Sitka Black-tailed Deer Odocoileus Hemionus sitkensis as an ecological indicator', Biol. Conserv. 66, 61–67.
Harig, A. L. and Bain, M. B.: 1998, 'Defining and restoring biological integrity in wilderness lakes', Ecol. Appl. 8, 71–87.
Harwell, M. A., Myers, V., Young, T., Bartuska, A., Gassman, N., Gentile, G. H., Harwell, C. C., Appelbaum, S., Barko, J., Causey, B., Johnson, C., McLean, A., Smola, R., Templet, P. and Tosini, S.: 1999, 'A framework for an ecosystem integrity report card', BioScience 49, 543–556.
Henjum, M. G.: 1996, 'Maintaining ecological integrity of inland forest ecosystems in Oregon and Washington', Wildl. Soc. Bull. 24, 227–232.
Herricks, E. and Schaeffer, D. J.: 1985, 'Can we optimize biomonitoring?', Env. Manage. 9, 487–492.
Hunter, M. L., Jacobson Jr., G. J. and Webb III, T.: 1988, 'Paleoecology and the coarse-filter approach to maintaining biological diversity', Conserv. Biol. 2, 375–385.
Hutto, R. L.: 1998, 'Using Landbirds as an Indicator Species Group', in: J. M. Marzluff, and R. Sallabanks (eds), Avian Conservation: Research and Management. Island Press, Washington (D.C.). p. 75–91.
Hutto, R. L., Reel, S. and Landres, P. B.: 1987, 'A critical evaluation of the species approach to biological conservation', Endangered Species Update 4, 1–4.
Järvinen, O., and Vaïsänen, R. A.: 1980, 'Quantitative biogeography of Finnish land birds as compared with regionality in other taxa', Ann. Zool. Fenn. 17, 67–85.
Karr, J. R.: 1981, 'Assessment of biotic integrity using fish communities', Fisheries 6, 21–27.
Karr, J. R.: 1991, 'Biotic integrity: A long-neglected aspect of water resource management', Ecol. Appl. 1, 66–84.
Karr, J. R. and Dudley, D. R.: 1981, 'Ecological perspective on water quality goals', Env. Manage. 5, 55–68.
Kay, J. J. and Schneider, E. D.: 1992, 'Thermodynamics and Measures of Ecological Integrity', in: D. H. McKenzie, D. E. Hyatt and V. J. McDonald (eds), Ecological Indicators. Elsevier Applied Science, New York. p. 159–181
Keddy, P. A., Lee, H. T. and Wisheu, I. C.: 1993, 'Choosing Indicators of Ecological Integrity: Wetlands as a Model System', in: S. Woodley, J. Kay and G. Francis (eds), Ecological Integrity and the Management of Ecosystems. St-Lucie Press, Florida. p. 61–82.
Kessler, W. B.: 1994, 'The Need for Ecosystem Vital Signs', in: D. W. McKenney, R. A. Sims, M. E. Soulé, B. G. Mackey and K. L. Campbell (eds.), Towards a Set of Biodiversity Indicators for Canadian Forests: Proceedings of a Forest Biodiversity Indicators Workshop. Natural Resources Canada, Sault Ste-Marie (Ontario). p. 92–97.
Koskimies, P.: 1989, Birds as a tool in environmental monitoring', Ann. Zool. Fenn. 26, 153–166.
Kremen, C.: 1992, 'Assessing the indicator properties of species assemblages for natural areas monitoring', Ecol. Appl. 2, 203–217.
Kremen, C.: 1994, 'Biological inventory using target taxa: a case study of the butterflies of Madagascar', Ecol. Appl. 4, 407–422.
Kriesel, W.: 1984, 'Representation of the environmental quality profile of a metropolitan area', Environ. Monit. Assess. 4, 15–33.
Lambeck, R. J.: 1997, 'Focal species: a multi-species umbrella for nature conservation', Conserv. Biol. 11, 849–856.
Landres, P. B.: 1992, 'Ecological Indicators: Panacea or Liability?', in: D. H. McKenzie, D. E. Hyatt and V. J. McDonald (eds), Ecological Indicators. Elsevier Applied Science, New York. p. 1295–1318.
Landres, P. B., Verner, J. and Thomas, J. W.: 1988, 'Ecological uses of vertebrate indicator species: a critique', Conserv. Biol. 2, 316–328.
Launer, A. E. and Murphy, D. D.: 1994, 'Umbrella species and the conservation of habitat fragments: A case of a threatened butterfly and a vanishing grassland ecosystem', Biol. Conserv. 69, 145–153.
Lindenmayer, D. B.: 1999, 'Future directions for biodiversity conservation in managed forests: indicator species, impact studies and monitoring programs', For. Ecol. Manage. 115, 277–287.
MacDonald, L. H. and Smart, A.: 1993, 'Beyond the guidelines: Practical lessons for monitoring', Environ. Monit. Assess. 26, 203–218.
Mackey, B. G., McKenney, D. W. and Sims, R. A.: 1994, 'Towards a Set of Biodiversity Indicators for Canadian Forests', in: D. W. McKenney, R. A. Sims, M. E. Soulé, B. G. Mackey and K. L. Campbell (eds), Towards a Set of Biodiversity Indicators for Canadian Forests: Proceedings of a Forest Biodiversity Indicators Workshop, Natural Resources Canada, Sault Ste-Marie (Ontario). p. 23–51.
Mannan, R. W., Morrison, M. L. and Meslow, E. C.: 1984, 'The use of guilds in forest bird management', Wildl. Soc. Bull. 12, 426–430.
Marshall, I. B., Hirvonen, H. and Wiken, E.: 1993, 'National and Regional Scale Measures of Canada's Ecosystem Health', in: S. Woodley, J. Kay and G. Francis (eds), Ecological Integrity and the Management of Ecosystems. St-Lucie Press (Florida). p. 117-130.
Martin, T. E.: 1995, 'Avian life history evolution in relation to nest sites, nest predation and food', Ecol. Monogr. 65, 101–127.
Martin, T. E. and Li, P.: 1992, 'Life history traits of open versus cavity-nesting birds' Ecology 73, 579–592.
Mazerolle, M. J. and Villard, M.-A.: 1999, 'Patch characteristics and landscape context as predictors of species presence and abundance: a review', Ecoscience 6, 117–124.
McKenney, D. W., Sims, R. A., Soulé, M. E. and Mackey, B. G.: 1994, 'Workshop Results', in: D. W. McKenney, R. A. Sims, M. E. Soulé, B. G. Mackey and K. L. Campbell (eds), Towards a Set of Biodiversity Indicators for Canadian Forests: Proceedings of a Forest Biodiversity Indicators Workshop. Natural Resources Canada, Sault Ste-Marie (Ontario). p. 1–22.
Morrison, M. L.: 1986, 'Bird populations as indicators of environmental change', Current Ornithol. 3, 429–451.
Moyle, P. B. and Randall, P. J.: 1998, 'Evaluating the biotic integrity of watersheds in the Sierra Nevada, California', Conserv. Biol. 12, 1318–1326.
Munn, R. E.: 1993, 'Monitoring for Ecosystem Integrity', in: S. Woodley, J. Kay, and G. Francis (eds), Ecological Integrity and the Management of Ecosystems. St-Lucie Press, Florida. p. 105–116.
Murphy, D. D., Freas, K. E. and Weiss, S. B.: 1990, 'An environmental-metapopulation approach to population viability analysis for a threatened invertebrate', Conserv. Biol. 4, 41–51.
Niemëla, J., Langor, D. and Spence, J. R.: 1993, 'Effects of clear-cut harvesting on boreal ground beetles assemblages (Coleoptera: Carabidae) in Western Canada', Conserv. Biol. 7, 551–561.
Niemi, G. J., Hanowski, J. M., Lima, A. R., Nicholls, T. and Weiland, N.: 1997, 'A critical analysis on the use of indicator species in management', J. Wildl. Manage. 61, 1240–1252.
Noss, R. F.: 1987, 'From plant communities to landscapes in conservation inventories: A look at the Nature Conservancy (U.S.A.)', Biol. Conserv. 41, 11–37.
Noss, R. F.: 1990, 'Indicators for monitoring biodiversity: A hierarchical approach', Conserv. Biol. 4, 355–264.
Noss, R. F.: 1999, 'Assessing and monitoring forest biodiversity: A suggested framework and indicators', For. Ecol. Manage. 115, 135–146.
Noss, R. F., O'Connell, M. A. and Murphy, D. D.: 1997, 'The Science of Conservation Planning: Habitat Conservation under the Endangered Species Act'. World Wildlife Fund et Island Press, Washington.
O'Connell, T. J., Jackson, L. E. and Brooks, R. P.: 1998, 'A bird community index of biotic integrity for the Mid-Atlantic highlands', Environ. Monit. Assess. 51, 145–156.
Paine, R. T.: 1969, 'A note on trophic complexity and community stability', Am. Nat. 103, 91–93.
Paine, R. T.: 1995, 'A conversation on refining the concept of keystone species', Conserv. Biol. 9, 962–964.
Pärt, T., and Söderström, B.: 1999a, 'Conservation value of semi-natural pastures in Sweden: contrasting botanical and avian measures', Conserv. Biol. 13, 755–765.
Pärt, T., and Söderström, B.: 1999b, 'The effects of management regimes and location in landscape on the conservation of farmland birds in semi-natural pastures', Biol. Conserv. 90, 113–123.
Pearson, D. L.: 1992, 'Tiger beetles as indicators of biodiversity patterns in Amazonia', Nat. Geogr. Res. Explor. 8, 116–117.
Pearson, D. L.: 1994, 'Selecting indicator taxa for the quantitative assessment of biodiversity', Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London 345, 75–79.
Pearson, D. L. and Cassola, F.: 1992, 'World-wide species richness patterns of tiger beetles (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae): indicator taxon for biodiversity and conservation studies', Conserv. Biol. 6, 376–391.
Powell, G. V. N. and Powell, A. H.: 1986, 'Reproduction by Great white herons Ardea herodias in Florida bay as an indicator of habitat quality', Biol. Conserv. 36, 101–113.
Prendergast, J. R. and Eversham, B. C.: 1997, 'Species covariance in higher taxa: Empirical tests of the biodiversity indicator concept', Ecography 20, 210–216.
Prendergast, J. R., Quinn, R. M., Lawton, J. H., Eversham, B. and Gibbons, D. H.: 1993, 'Are species, the coincidence of diversity hotspots and conservation strategies', Nature 365, 335–337.
Rapport, D. J.: 1989, 'What constitute ecosystem health?', Persp. Biol. Med. 33, 120–132.
Rapport, D. J.: 1990, 'Challenges in the detection and diagnosis of pathological change in aquatic ecosystems', J. Great Lakes Res. 16, 609–618.
Rapport, D. J.: 1992, 'Evolution of Indicators of Ecosystem Health', in: D. H. McKenzie, D. E. Hyatt and V. J. McDonald (eds), Ecological Indicators. Elsevier Applied Science, New York. p. 117–133.
Rapport, D. J.: 1995a, 'Ecosystem health: Exploring the territory', Ecosyst. Health 1, 5–13.
Rapport, D. J.: 1995b, 'Ecosystem health: More than a metaphor?', Env. Values 4, 287–309.
Reunanen, P., Mönkkönen, M. and Nikula, A.: 2000, 'Managing the boreal forest landscapes for flying squirrels', Conserv. Biol. 14, 218–226.
Riiters, K. H., Law, B. E., Kucera, R. C., Gallant, A. L., DeVelice, R. I. and Palmer, C. J.: 1992, 'A selection of forest condition indicators for monitoring', Environ. Monit. Assess. 20, 21–33.
Robbins, C. S., Dawson, D. K. and Dowell, B. A.: 1989, 'Habitat area requirements of breeding forest birds of the middle Atlantic states', Wildl. Monogr. 103, 1–34.
Roberts, T. H. and O'Neil, L. J.: 1985, 'Species selection for habitat assessments', Trans. N.A. Wildl. Nat. Res. Conf. 50, 352–362.
Rodrìguez, J. P., Pearson, D. L. and Barrera, R. R.: 1998, 'A test for the adequacy of bioindicator taxa: are tiger beetles (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) appropriate indicators for monitoring the degradation of tropical forests in Venezuela?', Biol. Conserv. 83, 69–76.
Schaeffer, D. J., Herricks, E. E. and Kerster, H.W.: 1988, 'Ecosystem health. I.Measuring ecosystem health', Env. Manage. 12, 445–455.
Schall, J. J. and Pianka, E. K.: 1978, 'Geographical trends in number of species', Science 201, 679–686.
Schoener, T. W.: 1986, 'Patterns in Terrestrial Vertebrates Versus Arthropod Communities: Do Systematic Differences in Regularity Exist?' in J. Diamond and T. J. Case (eds), Ecology. Harper and Row, New York (New York). p. 556–586.
Simberloff, D.: 1998, 'Flagships, umbrellas, and keystones: is single-species management passé in the landscape era?', Biol. Conserv. 83, 247–257.
Soulé, M. E. and Terborgh, J.: 1999, 'Conserving nature at regional and continental scales: a scientific program for North America', BioScience 49, 809–817.
Stanford, J. A. and Poole, G. C.: 1996, 'A protocol for ecosystem management', Ecol. Appl. 6, 741–744.
Starfield, A. M. and Bleloch, A. L.: 1983, 'An initial assessment of possible lion population indicators', S. Afr. J. Wildl. Res. 13, p9-11.
Steele, B. B., Bayn, R. L. Jr. and Grant, C. V.: 1984, 'Environmental monitoring using population of birds and small mammals: analyses of sampling effort', Biol. Conserv. 30, 157–172.
Suter II, G.W.: 1993, 'A critique of ecosystem health concepts and indexes', Env. Toxicol. Chem. 12, 1533–1539.
Temple, S. A. and Wiens, J. A.: 1989, 'Bird populations and environmental changes: can birds be bio-indicators?', Am. Birds 43, 260–270.
Tergorgh, J.: 1974, 'Preservation of natural diversity: the problem of extinction prone species', BioScience 24, 715–722.
Tilman, D., May, R. M., Lehman, C. L. and Nowak, M. A.: 1994, 'Habitat destruction and the extinction debt', Nature 371, 65–66.
Tracy, C. R. and Brussard, P. F.: 1994, 'Preserving biodiversity: species in landscapes', Ecol. Appl. 4, 205–207.
Tscharntke, T.: 1992, 'Fragmentation of Phragmites habitats, minimum viable population size, habitat suitability, and local extinction of moths, flies, aphids, and birds', Conserv. Biol. 6, 530–53.
Tscharntke, T., Gathmann, A. and Steffan-Dewenter, I.: 1998, 'Bioindication using trap-nesting bees and wasps and their natural enemies: community structure and interactions', J. Appl. Ecol. 35, 708–719.
Van Horne, B.: 1983, 'Density as a misleading indicator of habitat quality', J. Wildl. Manage. 47, 893–901.
Vickery, P. D., Hunter Jr., M.L. and Wells, J. V.: 1992, 'Is density an indicator of breeding success?', Auk 109, 706–710.
Villard, M.-A., Martin, P. and Drummond, G. C.: 1993, 'Habitat fragmentation and pairing success in the Ovenbird (Seiurus aurocapillus)', Auk 110, 759–768.
Villard, M.-A., Merriam, G. and Maurer, B. A.: 1995, 'Dynamics in subdivided populations of neotropical migratory birds in a temperate fragmented forest', Ecology 76, 27–40.
Weaver, J. C.: 1995, 'Indicator species and scale of observation', Conserv. Biol. 9, 939–942.
Welsh, H. H. Jr., Ollivier, L. M. and Hankin, D. G.: 1997, 'A habitat-based design for sampling and monitoring stream amphibians with an illustration from Redwood National Park', Northwestern Nat. 78, 1–16.
White, P. S. and Bratton, S. P.: 1980, 'After preservation: philosophical and practical problems of change', Biol. Conserv. 18, 241–255.
Wicklum, D. and Davies, R.W.: 1995, 'Ecosystem health and integrity?', Can. J. Bot. 73, 997–1000.
Wilcove, D.: 1994, 'Response to Franklin (1993)', Ecol. Appl. 4, 207–208.
Wilcove, D. S. and Blair, R. B.: 1995, 'The ecosystem management bandwagon', Trends Ecol. Evol. 10, 345.
Williams, P. H. and Gaston, K. J., 1994, 'Measuring more of biodiversity: Can higher-taxon richness predict wholesale species richness?', Biol. Conserv. 67, 211–217.
Woodley, S.: 1993, 'Monitoring and Measuring Ecosystem Integrity in Canadian National Parks', in: S. Woodley, J. Kay and G. Francis (eds), Ecological Integrity and theManagement of Ecosystems. St-Lucie Press, Florida. p. 155–176
Woodley, S.: 1996a, 'A scheme for ecological monitoring in national parks and protected areas', Environments 23, 50–59.
Woodley, S.: 1996b, 'Monitoring, assessing and reporting upon ecological change: implications for planning and management', Environments 24, 60–68.
Woodley, S. and Theberge, J.: 1992, 'Monitoring for Ecosystem Integrity in Canadian National Parks', in: J. H. M. Willison, S. Bondrup-Nielsen, C. Drysdale, T. B. Herman, N.W. P. Munro and T. L. Pollock (eds), Science and the Management of Protected Areas. Elsevier Applied Science, New York (New York). p. 369-377.
Zonneveld, I. S.: 1983, 'Principles of bioindication', Environ. Monit. Assess. 3, 207–217.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carignan, V., Villard, MA. Selecting Indicator Species to Monitor Ecological Integrity: A Review. Environ Monit Assess 78, 45–61 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016136723584
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016136723584